What is Animal Law?
Your animal law syllabus will vary depending upon where you study animal law (see �Animal Law Courses� for details of who to contact for a syllabus). However, examples of issues that have been raised in the courts are as follows:- Can a chimpanzee be the subject of a habeas corpus?
- Is a dolphin a ‘person’ for the defence of necessity to a charge of theft?
- Should the death of a monkey used in scientific experimentation be classed as an ‘adverse effect’ in assessing the costs of granting a project licence?
- Can a chicken be deliberately reared so that it is chronically hungry for much of its life?
The study of animal law raises fascinating questions such as these and
enables students to critically analyse the laws which address them. For
example, in 2004 the court interpreted legislation which provides that
chickens must be “fed a wholesome diet … in sufficient quantity
to maintain them in good health” in such a way that it is legal
to keep breeder chickens chronically hungry for much of their lives. How
did the court reach this decision and what are its implications?
What is particularly interesting about animal law as an academic subject
is that law and ethics are inextricably linked. Animal law students not
only analyse the wording of a statute, they also delve into ethical discussions.
For example, is it right for chickens to be kept chronically hungry when
a slower-growing genotype could be used? This invites questions as to
the nature of our moral obligation to other sentient beings. Do the chickens
in fact suffer and if so, is that suffering necessary? These are the types
of challenging questions faced by animal law students.
The Animal Welfare Act 2006 made significant changes to the law. The offence of causing unnecessary suffering to some domestic animals remains a pivotal concept and students can expect some interesting debates on the nature of the necessity of animal suffering. The significant change in the law comes in the form of a new welfare offence which introduces a positive duty on owners to ensure the welfare of protected animals. This enables organisations such as the RSPCA to intervene before the animal actually suffers. It will be interesting to assess the effects of this new offence.
A particularly exciting area of animal law concerns the question of whether animals can be legal persons. At present the law divides persons from things. Only humans (and companies created by humans) enjoy the status of a legal person and have rights. Animals are ‘things’ at law and cannot have legal rights. There are, however, laws to protect the welfare of some animals. But there is now a strong argument for granting some animals, e.g., adult chimpanzees, some basic legal rights, e.g. freedom from torture and slavery. Attempts have been made in a number of recent international cases to challenge the status quo. This is cutting-edge law which promises exciting times ahead.
The study of animal law may include any of the following topics: